Why I F*cking Hate the Gather Table

I f*cking hate, HATE, absofreakinglutely loathe the Gather Table. I cannot type enough words to convey to you how horrible this thing is. On my phone, I keep a list of things I hate without notes, and the Gather Table is pretty close to one of the first things I wrote down.

The Gather Table is a sleeper. You stumble across it on DWR and at first glance she is beauty, she is grace. She fully embraces her Japandi simplicity and clean-lined nature with beautifully scaled supports and sexy legs. She is hot. Her wood tones are not too yellow and her table space is gracious. There is a crisp shadow line right down the center where the two planks join to create one larger table, and the overhang is generous enough that no knee gets bonked upon scooting in. But this is where it ends.

• 

• 

• 

Just as the beauty is in the details — so is the devil. For starters, this table is $9,000. Fine, we are shopping at Design Out of Reach anyway, so the price tag is expected. What is NOT expected is that for my $9k I get a pile of poplar, skinned in veneer and, ever so kindly, edged in solid wood. In the world of materials, they have dressed up the pig.

To convey just how much con artistry is at work here, let's step out of the rant for a moment and build a little knowledge base — two things: wood and veneer.

In the world of wood, there is a hierarchy of quality. Just as in apparel we go from polyester to silk, the same holds true here. At the floor of the barrel sits MDF — not even wood, just compressed sawdust and glue, and the core of much of today's furniture. Then we have our offender: Poplar — technically a hardwood, practically a liability. Soft, dents easily, takes paint fine, and economical — which is why it's used so readily. Followed closely by Rubberwood (a plantation byproduct) and then Pine. Scaling up we hit the mid-range of Alder, Birch, and Beech. We get more serious with Maple, Ash, and Red Oak, and then arrive at my favorite grouping: White Oak, Cherry, Walnut, and Teak.

Now onto veneer — not to be confused with its uglier cousin, laminate, but that rant is for another day. Veneer is a thin slice of real wood — typically 0.5mm to 3mm thick — glued over a substrate. The substrate is almost always something cheap: MDF, particle board, poplar, birch plywood. Veneer is the face. Everything you see and touch is real wood. Everything underneath is… Questionable?

Veneer has a rich past — ancient Egyptians used it. For most of its history it was a legitimate technique for using rare, beautiful, expensive wood efficiently. You have a slab of walnut burl. You slice it thin. Now one slab becomes 40 surfaces. You can also do things with veneer that you can't do with solid wood — book-matching grain patterns across a surface so they mirror each other, creating a symmetry solid wood cannot produce. Fine antiques use veneer and they're still standing 200 years later. So veneer is not inherently a lie. Today's veneer is.

So why have we historically used it? Stability and sustainability. Solid wood moves. It expands and contracts with humidity and temperature. A large solid wood tabletop will warp and crack over time if it's not properly constructed and cared for — and even then. Veneer over a stable substrate like plywood doesn't move the same way. This is the "superior resistance to warping and cracking" line DWR is using, and it's not technically wrong. It's just a convenient way to make a limitation sound like a celebrated engineering decision.

So knowing all of this, you may still ask: where does the Gather Table go wrong?

The thickness. Modern commercial veneer is often less than 1mm. You cannot sand it. You cannot refinish it. When it gets scratched or dull, it stays that way forever. The Gather Table says "extra-thick veneer" — extra-thick compared to paper-thin is still nothing.

The edges. Veneer has to be hidden at the edges, because the edge is where it fails first — it chips, it lifts, it delaminates. That's why the Gather Table has solid wood edging. They're patching the weak point and calling it a feature.

It doesn't like life. Heat, moisture, impact. All the things that happen at a dining table. Veneer is glued down. Glue fails. A hot dish without a trivet, a water ring that sits too long, a knock from a chair — over time these things lift and bubble in ways solid wood just absorbs.

You can't bring it back. A solid wood table gets scratched, you sand it. Gets dull, you refinish it. Gets damaged, you repair it. A veneered table, when it's done, is done.

And girl, do not get me started on the one-year warranty. On a $9,000 table. The manufacturer knows exactly what they're doing. Go ahead and apply that lipstick.

• 

So here we are. I hope, if you've made it this far, you now want to add the Gather Table to your own list of hated things. But the sad part is it doesn't have to be this way. We do not need to buy these con artist items. We as consumers can do better.

DWR designed this table and then named it Gather. The one thing it is named to do is the very thing that will be its demise. Heat, spills, rings, people — LIFE. That table should be etched with the rich history of the love and the family that spent countless hours making it their home. Instead it will be cursed, patched, and eventually replaced rather than passed down to the next generation to love and make their own memories.

To gather.